DOCUMENTS RELEASED under the Freedom of Information Act indicate that John Perry, was the only Government Oireachtas member from the Sligo/North Leitrim constituency who made written representations relating to the Breast Cancer service, to the Minister for Health in the period from the new Government was appointed in March to the end of June. Cllr Declan Bree said today.
“There is no record of any of the other government T.D or Senators from this area making written representations to the Minister for Health regarding the reinstatement of the Cancer Service.” said Cllr Bree.
“There is not one letter on file from Deputy Tony McLoughlin, Senator Imelda Henry, Senator Susan O’Keefe, or Senator Michael Comiskey. Nor is there any record or minutes of the Fine Gael/Labour Oireachtas members having a meeting with the Minister for Health to discuss the reinstatement of the Breast Cancer Service to Sligo General Hospital.
“On the basis of the official records held by the Department of Health the only formal meeting with T.D’s and Senators took place on the 23rd June, and that was a meeting with a cross party delegation of Oireachtas members from the region.
“It’s as if the Fine Gael and Labour Oireachtas members from Sligo-Leitrim forgot about the restoration of the Breast Cancer service once they managed to get themselves into Leinster House.” said Cllr Bree.
“In a letter from Minister of State John Perry to the Minister for Health James Reilly, on the 1st of April relating to the reinstatement of the Symptomatic Breast Unit, Deputy Perry said, “This was a pledge that was made by yourself (James Reilly) as Fine Gael Health Spokesperson at a public meeting in March 2010 in the Sligo Park Hotel (whereby were Fine Gael in government within the subsequent 12 months the service would be reinstated) and was also reaffirmed during the recent election campaign.”
Deputy Perry went on “In addition, the Tanaiste also gave a commitment pre-election, in his capacity as Labour Party Leader, that Sligo would become a 9th Centre of Excellence should Labour be elected to government. While I realise that this is an unlikely prospect, what is essential is that the services which were removed, i.e. the Symptomatic Breast Unit, are now reinstated.
“It is now a matter of credibility for the government, notwithstanding the detrimental effect the lack of such services have on the people of this region.
“The onus is therefore on us as a government to ensure that the pre election pledges are delivered upon as a matter of the utmost priority and that the services removed by the previous administration are put back in place as soon as possible.” said Minister Perry in his letter.
In a reply the Minister for Health James Reilly ignored the issues raised in John Perry’s letter and stated that he would “shortly meet with Dr Susan O’Reilly, Director of the National Cancer Control Programme, to discuss a range of strategic issues in relation to cancer services, including the provision of breast cancer services at Sligo General Hospital.”
The documentation also confirms that the Director of the National Cancer Control Programme, Dr Susan O’Reilly, refused to meet with Minister of State John Perry following a request for a meeting from Minister Perry.
Other documents released include an email dated 19th May from Dr Mary Hynes, Cancer Network Manager West, National Cancer Control Programme to Ms Mary Jackson Principal Officer, Cancer Policy unit of the Department of Health referring to a question on the restoration of the Breast Cancer service submitted to the HSE by Cllr Declan Bree for the Regional Health Forum meeting in Galway on the 24th May.
Another email dated 16th June from Dr Hynes to Ms Jackson refers to a notice of motion and a question on the reestablishment of the Breast Cancer services which Cllr Bree submitted for the Regional Health Forum meeting of the 21st June.
The documents confirm that the Minister for Health met with Dr Susan O’Reilly, the Director of the National Cancer Control Programme on the 15th of April, where she outlined the cancer services provided at Sligo General Hospital. According to the internal notes of the meeting the Director “confirmed that breast surgery had moved to Galway in line with agreed protocols.”
Speaking this week Cllr Bree said “on the basis of the released documentation it is obvious that the Fine Gael and Labour Oireachtas members did little or nothing to have the breast cancer services restored to Sligo General Hospital.
“Minister Perry was the only one to make written submissions and it is clear that his efforts were ineffectual. To add insult to injury the Director of the National Cancer Control Programme, Dr Susan O’Reilly, refused to meet with Minister Perry to discuss the cancer services in Sligo.
“I fear now that the Fine Gael and Labour representatives have no intention of honouring their promises and commitments. If the breast cancer service is not restored and if it is the case that the issue of the cancer service was used solely to win votes, then the Fine Gael and Labour representatives in the Dail and Senate will pay a heavy price.” Cllr Bree warned.